| Class | Team | First Name | Last Name | School | Position |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5A | First Team | Aislenn | Whitzel | Carlsbad High School | Catcher |
| 5A | First Team | Kendal | Lunar | Alamogordo High School | Catcher |
| 5A | First Team | Amanda | Valles | Centennial High School | First Base |
| 5A | First Team | Karissa | Garcia | Hobbs High School | First Base |
| 5A | First Team | Grace | Aragon | Carlsbad High School | Infielder |
| 5A | First Team | Johnna | Aragon | Carlsbad High School | Infielder |
| 5A | First Team | Mya | Pacheco | Cleveland High School | Infielder |
| 5A | First Team | Tavia | Fragua | Cleveland High School | Infielder |
| 5A | First Team | Lanae | Billy | Piedra Vista High School | Infielder |
| 5A | First Team | Jessica | Munro | Carlsbad High School | Outfielder |
| 5A | First Team | Gianna | Villegas | Centennial High School | Outfielder |
| 5A | First Team | Mercedes | Lovato | Cleveland High School | Outfielder |
| 5A | First Team | Ajah | Charlie | Piedra Vista High School | Outfielder |
| 5A | First Team | Sydney | Lessentine | Alamogordo High School | Pitcher |
| 5A | First Team | Faith | Aragon | Carlsbad High School | Pitcher |
| 5A | First Team | Haiven | Schoolcraft | Carlsbad High School | Pitcher |
| 5A | Second Team | Monet | Chavez | Centennial High School | Catcher |
| 5A | Second Team | Anaya | Rodriguez | Hobbs High School | Catcher |
| 5A | Second Team | Talyssa | Espinoza | Roswell High School | Catcher |
| 5A | Second Team | Ashlyn | Zapach | La Cueva High School | First Base |
| 5A | Second Team | Allyson | Herrod | Farmington High School | First Base |
| 5A | Second Team | Hannah | Martinez | Carlsbad High School | Infielder |
| 5A | Second Team | Stevie | Jimenez | Centennial High School | Infielder |
| 5A | Second Team | Kayla | Hernandez | Centennial High School | Infielder |
| 5A | Second Team | Jalyn | Montes | Cibola High School | Infielder |
| 5A | Second Team | Madison | Begaye | Rio Rancho High School | Infielder |
| 5A | Second Team | Edyth | Chavez | Hobbs High School | Outfielder |
| 5A | Second Team | Jayden | Ybarra | Mayfield High School | Outfielder |
| 5A | Second Team | Kayla | Reed | Rio Rancho High School | Outfielder |
| 5A | Second Team | Kylie | Taff | Volcano Vista High School | Outfielder |
| 5A | Second Team | Caprice | Barela | Centennial High School | Pitcher |
| 5A | Second Team | Rikki | Wilkie | Farmington High School | Pitcher |
| 5A | Second Team | Akaysia | Grogan | Piedra Vista High School | Pitcher |