| i | Position | First Name | Last Name | School |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Honorable Mention | Inside Linebacker | Joshua | Baca | Magdalena High School |
| Honorable Mention | Defensive Line | Kash | Begay | Navajo Pine High School |
| Honorable Mention | Inside Linebacker | James | Benjamin | Mesilla Valley Christian School |
| First Team | Offensive Lineman | Joaquin | Billy | Magdalena High School |
| First Team | Defensive Line | Jaryn | Bruce | Melrose High School |
| Second Team | Defensive End | Brock | Burns | Logan High School |
| Honorable Mention | Offensive Lineman | Zack | Byrd | Logan High School |
| Second Team | Defensive Line | Zack | Byrd | Logan High School |
| First Team | Punter | Michael | Cardonita | Melrose High School |
| First Team | Secondary | Michael | Cardonita | Melrose High School |
| Second Team | Quarterback | Michael | Cardonita | Melrose High School |
| Second Team | Center | Skyler | Deluca | Logan High School |
| Second Team | Defensive Line | Skyler | Deluca | Logan High School |
| Second Team | Offensive Lineman | Logan | DeVaney | Melrose High School |
| First Team | Kicker | Cy | Draper | Melrose High School |
| First Team | Receiver | Abraham | Duran | Tatum High School |
| First Team | Secondary | Abraham | Duran | Tatum High School |
| First Team | Outside Linebacker | Luke | Field | Tatum High School |
| Honorable Mention | Receiver | Brandon | Garcia | Melrose High School |
| Second Team | Secondary | Brandon | Garcia | Melrose High School |
| First Team | Quarterback | Taylor | Garner | Tatum High School |
| First Team | Outside Linebacker | Tyler | Graham | Tatum High School |
| First Team | Defensive End | Samuel | Harris | Tatum High School |
| First Team | Offensive Lineman | Samuel | Harris | Tatum High School |
| Honorable Mention | Offensive Lineman | Fabian | Herrera | Menaul High School |
| Second Team | Outside Linebacker | Anthony | Jones | Menaul High School |
| Second Team | Secondary | Haden | Judd | Logan High School |
| Honorable Mention | Tight End | Dylan | Keeto | Navajo Pine High School |
| Second Team | Slot | Izaiah | Kneitz | Logan High School |
| Honorable Mention | Secondary | Christian | Kotara | Logan High School |
| First Team | Tight End | Ranley | Krueger | Tatum High School |
| Second Team | Defensive End | Ranley | Krueger | Tatum High School |
| Second Team | Offensive Lineman | Tanyon | Lambert | Tatum High School |
| Honorable Mention | Defensive End | Garrett | Lerch | Menaul High School |
| First Team | Running back | Saul | Marquez | Fort Sumner High School |
| First Team | Center | Nash | Martin | Melrose High School |
| First Team | Defensive End | Nash | Martin | Melrose High School |
| First Team | Defensive Line | Brody | McAlister | Melrose High School |
| First Team | Offensive Lineman | Brody | McAlister | Melrose High School |
| First Team | Secondary | David | Mendoza | Tatum High School |
| Honorable Mention | Receiver | David | Mendoza | Tatum High School |
| First Team | Inside Linebacker | Hayden | Mullins | Tatum High School |
| First Team | Running back | Hayden | Mullins | Tatum High School |
| Honorable Mention | Outside Linebacker | Payson | Nials | Logan High School |
| First Team | Receiver | Clay | Norman | Fort Sumner High School |
| Honorable Mention | Outside Linebacker | Tavian | Nutlouis | Navajo Pine High School |
| Second Team | Running back | Jaxon | Odom | Melrose High School |
| Honorable Mention | Running back | Danny | Pino | Magdalena High School |
| Honorable Mention | Defensive Line | Aaron | Plummer | Navajo Pine High School |
| Honorable Mention | Quarterback | Joaquin | Segura | Fort Sumner High School |
| Honorable Mention | Outside Linebacker | Nalin | Slivers | Navajo Pine High School |
| Second Team | Offensive Lineman | Brady | Sorgen | Melrose High School |
| Second Team | Receiver | Kaeden | Stoner | Logan High School |
| Second Team | Secondary | Kaeden | Stoner | Logan High School |
| First Team | Inside Linebacker | Park | Strong | Logan High School |
| First Team | Slot | Park | Strong | Logan High School |
| Second Team | Kicker | Park | Strong | Logan High School |
| Second Team | Punter | Park | Strong | Logan High School |
| Second Team | Inside Linebacker | Junior | Vigil | Fort Sumner High School |
| Second Team | Inside Linebacker | Dathan | Yeary | Melrose High School |
| Second Team | Running back | Dathan | Yeary | Melrose High School |