2019 4A 1st Team Defense
| Philip | Blidi | Portales | FB- Defensive Lineman |
| Jeremy | Burnham | Bloomfield | FB- Defensive Lineman |
| Wromiah | Gbassagee | Portales | FB- Defensive Lineman |
| Isiah | Saiz | Portales | FB- Inside Linbacker |
| JT | Seitzinger | Bloomfield | FB- Inside Linbacker |
| Kenyon | Mosley | Bloomfield | OLB/DE |
| Dason | Davis | Portales | OLB/DE |
| Jalen | Allen | Portales | FB- Secondary |
| Jordan | Garcia | Portales | FB- Secondary |
| Julian | Fuentes | Lovington | FB- Secondary |
| Bryce | Perez | Bloomfield | FB- Secondary |
| Owen | Smith | Portales | FB- Kicker |
2019 4A 1st Team Offense
| Casey | Perez | Lovington | FB- Quarterback |
| Wromiah | Gbassagee | Portales | FB- Running Back |
| Kenyon | Mosley | Bloomfield | FB- Running Back |
| Isaiah | Johnson | Grants | FB- Running Back |
| Philip | Blidi | Portales | FB- Offensive Lineman |
| Fabien | Olivas | Portales | FB- Offensive Lineman |
| Lucas | Tarin | Lovington | FB- Offensive Lineman |
| Antonio | Anderson | Lovington | FB- Offensive Lineman |
| Jamie | Rios | Bloomfield | FB- Offensive Lineman |
| Kellan | Hightower | Portales | FB- Receiver |
| Jalen | Allen | Portales | FB- Receiver |
| Noah | Gurule | Bloomfield | FB- Receiver |
| Grant | Oberheu | Ruidoso | FB- Tight End |
| Layson | Powell | Ruidoso | FB- Punter |
2019 4A 2nd Team Defense
| Alexander | Tramell | Lovington | FB- Defensive Lineman |
| Carlos | De La Rosa | Lovington | FB- Defensive Lineman |
| Ian | Thomas | Kirtland Central | FB- Defensive Lineman |
| Enrique | Gonzalez | Lovington | FB- Inside Linbacker |
| Austin | Jaime | Aztec | FB- Inside Linbacker |
| Justin | Paden | Portales | OLB/DE |
| Alex | Parra | Aztec | OLB/DE |
| Tomas | Gonzales | Bloomfield | FB- Secondary |
| Ayden | Garcia | Lovington | FB- Secondary |
| Ryan | McCormick | St. Pius X | FB- Secondary |
| Xavier | Ramirez | Grants | FB- Secondary |
2019 4A 2nd Team Offense
| Vince | Marquez | Bloomfield | FB- Quarterback |
| Baylor | Diaz | Portales | FB- Quarterback |
| Alex | Parra | Aztec | FB- Running Back |
| TJ | Hocker | Grants | FB- Running Back |
| Trebor | Toledo | St. Pius X | FB- Running Back |
| Santiago | Salazar | Taos | FB- Offensive Lineman |
| Cephrin | Lujan | Bloomfield | FB- Offensive Lineman |
| Kolby | Taylor | Silver | FB- Offensive Lineman |
| Josh | Cowden | Aztec | FB- Offensive Lineman |
| Michael | Maes | Bernalillo | FB- Offensive Lineman |
| Adam | Aguilera | Lovington | FB- Receiver |
| Isaiah | Griffin | St. Pius X | FB- Receiver |
| Layson | Powell | Ruidoso | FB- Receiver |
| Ty | Jenks | Kirtland Central | FB- Kicker |