4A/5A 1st Team Offense (2016)
| Center | Devin | Christian | Moriarty |
| Guard | Santiago | Mora | Moriarty |
| Guard | Clayton | Connors | Belen |
| Kick Returner | Elijah | Tapia | Moriarty |
| Punter | Garrett | Gallegos | Belen |
| Quarterback | Drew | Ortiz | St. Pius |
| Receiver | Isaiah | Escajeda | Hope Christian |
| Receiver | Mel | DeHerrera | St. Pius |
| Receiver | Hunter | Wisneski | Los Lunas |
| Runningback | Avery | See | Del Norte |
| Runningback | O'Maury | Samuels | Los Lunas |
| Tackle | Austin | Barnes | Del Norte |
| Tackle | Estevan | Chavez | Belen |
| TE/Slot | Ryan | McGaha | St. Pius |
| TE/Slot | Dylan | DiLorenzo | St. Pius |
4A/5A 1st Team Defense (2016)
| Corner | Christian | Brewster | Los Lunas |
| Corner | Dominic | Garcia | Belen |
| DE/OLB | Adrian | Leon | St. Pius |
| DE/OLB | Elijah | Tapia | Moriarty |
| Defensive Line | Travis | Burson | Moriarty |
| Defensive Line | Jaron | Markland | Belen |
| Defensive Line | Brenden | Alcala | St. Pius |
| Kicker | Vince | Quezada | Hope Christian |
| Linebacker | Austin | Shull | St. Pius |
| Linebacker | Santiago | Mora | Moriarty |
| Linebacker | Trevor | Brohard | Los Lunas |
| Linebacker | Avery | See | Del Norte |
| Safety | Mario | Chavez | Bernalillo |
| Safety | Sam | Chavez | St. Pius |
4A/5A 2nd Team Offense (2016)
| Center | John | Corcoran | St. Pius |
| Guard | Roderick | Blackwell | Del Norte |
| Guard | Evan | Lavin | St. Pius |
| Kick Returner | Marcos | Medina | Hope Christian |
| Punter | Damian | Gutierrez | Bernalillo |
| Quarterback | Nicholas | Gaerlan | Los Lunas |
| Receiver | Martin | Trujillo | Los Lunas |
| Receiver | Aaron | Murphy | Moriarty |
| Receiver | Trey | Arthor | Hope Christian |
| Runningback | Elijah | Tapia | Moriarty |
| Runningback | Diego | Casillas | Belen |
| Tackle | Roman | Garcia | St. Pius |
| Tackle | Isaac | Kincaid | Belen |
| TE/Slot | Brandon | Carrejo | Belen |
| TE/Slot | Trevor | Brohard | Los Lunas |
4A/5A 2nd Team Defense (2016)
| Corner | Trevion | Lewis | Del Norte |
| Corner | Tyler | Murphy | Moriarty |
| DE/OLB | Jared | Vigil | St. Pius |
| DE/OLB | Rowdy | Robinson | Belen |
| Defensive Line | Julian | Garcia | Hope Christian |
| Defensive Line | Michael | Chino | Del Norte |
| Defensive Line | Joesph | Brakenhoff | St. Pius |
| Kicker | Shawn | Kelly-Romero | Los Lunas |
| Linebacker | Carlos | Duran | Bernalillo |
| Linebacker | Diego | Casillas | Belen |
| Safety | Branden | Call | Del Norte |
| Safety | Tyler | Justice | Los Lunas |