2016 4A First Team Offense
| QB: | Junior Ramirez | Portales |
| RB: | Darion Ontiveros | Portales |
| RB: | Xavier Vigil | St. Michaels |
| RB: | JP Griego | Robertson |
| Off. Lineman | Jeremie Karnghaye | Portales |
| Off. Lineman | Ryan Montez | Hatch Valley |
| Off. Lineman | Darren Duran | Robertson |
| Off. Lineman | Santiago Mora | Moriarty |
| Off. Lineman | Sean Lave | St. Michaels |
| TE/Slot | Tyris Newton | Shiprock |
| W. Receiver | Cade Hackey | Hatch Valley |
| W. Receiver | Esteban Alcarez | St. Michaels |
| Punter | Cooper Carson | Hatch Valley |
2016 4A First Team Defense
| LB | Xavier Vigil | St. Michaels |
| LB | Connor Houdack | Robertson |
| LB | Isaiah Lucero | Portales |
| DE/OLB | Emilo Lovato | Portales |
| DE/OLB | Darion Ontiveros | Portales |
| Defensive Line | Jeremie Karngbay | Portales |
| Defensive Line | Ryan Montez | Hatch Valley |
| Defensive Line | Trenton Small | Portales |
| Secondary | Arjay Ortiz | Robertson |
| Secondary | Cade Hackey | Hatch Valley |
| Secondary | Thomas Tulk | Portales |
| Secondary | Isaiah Otero | Ruidoso |
| Kicker | Saul Trujillo | Hatch Valley |
| Returner | Rahkeem Anagale | Shiprock |
2016 4A Second Team Offense
| QB | Cooper Carson | Hatch Valley |
| QB | Arjay Ortiz | Robertson |
| RB | Saul Trujillo | Hatch Valley |
| RB | Elijah Tapia | Moriarty |
| RB | Cisco Mayville | Ruidoso |
| Off. Lineman | Morgan Dunnahoo | Hatch Valley |
| Off. Lineman | Devin Christian | Moriarty |
| Off. Lineman | Damen Guck | Cobre |
| Off. Lineman | Babatunde Okundaye | Robertson |
| Off. Lineman | Cassius Trujillo | W. Las Vegas |
| TE/Slot | Mario Chavez | Bernalillo |
| W. Receiver | Christian Padilla | NMMI |
| W. Receiver | Ronnie Salazar | Taos |
| Punter | Emilio Lovato | Portales |
2016 4A Second Team Defense
| LB | Santiago Mora | Moriarty |
| LB | Cooper Carson | Hatch Valley |
| LB | Curtis Rogers | St. Michaels |
| DE/OLB | Patrick Dalton | St. Michaels |
| DE/OLB | Joseph Gallardo | Cobre |
| Defensive Line | Darian Duran | Robertson |
| Defensive Line | Devon Christian | Moriarty |
| Defensive Line | Tony Gomez | Cobre |
| Secondary | Andru Sanchez | Cobre |
| Secondary | Tyler Murphy | Moriarty |
| Secondary | Rodney Salazar | Taos |
| Secondary | Saul Trujillo | Hatch Valley |
| Kicker | Vince Quezada | Hope Christian |