2016 5A First Team Offense
| QB | Drew Ortiz | St. Pius |
| RB | O'Maury Samuels | Los Lunas |
| RB | Gabe Najar | Roswell |
| RB | Devon Quiroz | Goddard |
| Off. Lineman | Nathaniel Zarazua | Artesia |
| Off. Lineman | Marcus Bramwell | Artesia |
| Off. Lineman | Anthony Silva | Roswell |
| Off. Lineman | John Corcoran | St. Pius |
| Off. Lineman | Evan Lavin | St. Pius |
| TE/Slot | Ryan McGaha | St. Pius |
| W. Receiver | Mel DeHerrera | St. Pius |
| W. Receiver | Martin Trujillo | Los Lunas |
| Punter | Kyle Hooper | Alamogordo |
2016 5A First Team Defense
| LB | Trevor Brohard | Los Lunas |
| LB | Austin Shull | St. Pius |
| LB | Miguel Martinez | Artesia |
| DE/OLB | Adrian Leon | St. Pius |
| DE/OLB | Codey Scott | Artesia |
| Defensive Line | Donald Truex | Roswell |
| Defensive Line | Joseph Brakenhoff | St. Pius |
| Defensive Line | Jharyss Granger | Artesia |
| Secondary | Hunter Wisneski | Los Lunas |
| Secondary | Sam Chavez | St. Pius |
| Secondary | Chase Thompson | Artesia |
| Secondary | Dacton Bowles | Goddard |
| Kicker | Brett Money | Alamogordo |
| Kicker | Shawn Kelly-Romero | Los Lunas |
| Returner | Ryan McGaha | St. Pius |
2016 5A Second Team Offense
| QB | Taylor Null | Artesia |
| RB | Avery See | Del Norte |
| RB | Danilan Smith | Alamogordo |
| RB | Junior Vargas | Capital |
| Off. Lineman | Victor Bolanos | Roswell |
| Off. Lineman | Dewey Huffman | Alamogordo |
| Off. Lineman | Isaac Montes | Goddard |
| Off. Lineman | Kyle Keeler | Miyamura |
| Off. Lineman | Nathan Reuss | Alamogordo |
| Off. Lineman | Estevan Chavez | Belen |
| TE/Slot | Dylan DiLorenzo | St. Pius |
| W. Receiver | Sebastian McNeal | Aztec |
| W. Receiver | Alex Ramirez | Alamogordo |
| Punter | Justin Williams | Farmington |
2016 5A Second Team Defense
| LB | Avery See | Del Norte |
| LB | Luis Mendoza | Roswell |
| LB | Kobe Ramage | Goddard |
| DE/OLB | Andres Villa | Goddard |
| DE/OLB | Jared Vigil | St. Pius |
| Defensive Line | Misael Zaragosa | Goddard |
| Defensive Line | Jarron Markland | Belen |
| Defensive Line | Dewey Huffman | Alamogordo |
| Secondary | Vince Montoya | St. Pius |
| Secondary | Kody Becenti | Farmington |
| Secondary | Christian Brewster | Los Lunas |
| Secondary | Alex Alton | Alamogordo |
| Kicker | Riley Barker | Aztec |
| Returner | Alex Ramirez | Alamogordo |